Bruce Montague
Bill C-68 Court Challenge
CCF Takes Montague Case | News | Sign-Up for email-updates | donate Donate
This Case Epilogue written February 1, 2017 is intended to provide context to this web site as it documents a Canadian constitutional challenge spanning from 2004 to 2016. Bruce Montague determined to expose the constitutional violations in the Canadian Firearms Act. After being charged, mounting a constitutional challenge and appealing to the Supreme Court of Canada, Montague's case was dismissed without reasons. With Bruce in jail, the Montagues then faced an another twist of injustice -- the confiscation of their home and property by the Ontario government. The Montagues fought the civil forfeiture of their home for years until, in the summer of 2016, the Canadian Constitution Foundation was instrumental in negotiating with the Ontario Civil Forfeiture department to drop the lien against the Montague home. The Canadian Constitution Foundation deserves our support as they continue to fight other cases of injustice around the country. YOU COULD BE NEXT! Canada is undergoing a quiet revolution and your fundamental rights and freedoms are at stake!
What's Wrong with Civil Forfeiture» | Write to Stop Civil Forfeiture»

News Archive


Site Map

Sep20: Gunsmith spends over a week in jail

News Archive Index
Date: Sept 20, 2004
Source: Dryden Observer

By Laurie Papineau

After 10 days and two scheduled Show Cause hearings, Bruce Montague was still waiting to find out if he would be released from jail on Tuesday.

The Dryden gunsmith and Canadian Unregistered Firearms Owners Association (CUFOA) member was charged with a number of weapons related offences on Sept. 11 after openly refusing to register his firearms in an act of ongoing non-compliance with Bill C-68.

After a search warrant was executed on the family's property, Montague was facing four charges, including two counts of unauthorized possession of firearms and careless storage of a firearm; failure to use reasonable care with an explosive and unlawful possession of an explosive. His wife Donna was charged with unauthorized possession of a firearm and careless storage.

However, by the time Montague appeared at bail court for a Show Cause hearing in Dryden on Sept. 15, the number of weapons related charges against him had grown to at least half a dozen.

The hearing was halted when Montague decided against defending himself, but not until the Crown's first witness had provided details of what was found during the search of the family's home.

At least 55 firearms, numerous rounds of ammunition, and six sticks of dynamite in the family freezer were among the items OPP Det. Const. Randy Belluz said were seized from the home. This led the police officer to later describe Montague's character as "paranoid."

This comment angered supporters and family members who made note of the fact that it's not unusual for a gunsmith and firearms collector to possess these items, adding that the dynamite was used for clearing a beaver dam and many of the guns found at that time belonged to customers.

The Dryden man had dozens of supporters in court for the hearing, many who had little, if anything, to do with firearms. Most of them expressed relief that Montague would enlist professional help in his bid to get out of jail.

For a second attempt at the Show Cause hearing in Kenora on Sept. 20, the family had retained the services of Thornhill, ON lawyer Edward Burlew.

Burlew, an avid hunter, shooter and gun collector, has traveled all over Ontario in his 25 years of practice, and has handled a number of weapons related offences he calls "paper crimes."

"The majority of my clients are middle aged, hard working families who have had a break-in, fire or medical emergency at their homes, and end up with charges against them after the police come in and see a firearm," says Burlew. "This tells me that gun owners are at high risk of getting into trouble with the law."

After going over the details of Montague's case, the lawyer says what his client is facing is "paper non-compliance charges."

"Bruce has some very strong constitutional arguments on his side," he notes. "We're going to take this as far as we can."

Montague's team is hoping to prove that these charges under Bill C-68, constitute a violation of his rights and freedoms guaranteed under the Charter. That may mean a trip to the Supreme Court, but Burlew says his client is prepared for the battle.

Many supporters who made the trip to Kenora, hoping to watch that battle begin were disappointed when Crown attorney Peter Keen and Burlew came to an agreement involving Montague's release without ever stepping foot in the courtroom.

At the end of the day, the gunsmith agreed to divulge the location and safe entry of a secret room in the family home - a room not found during the initial 36-hour search.

On the evening of Sept. 20, a second search warrant was executed at the Montague's property, and pending the location of numerous firearms still believed to be in his possession, Montague was to be released in Sioux Lookout bail court on Sept. 21.

As of press time, however, the Crown was waiting for the police report on the second search and indicating that there may be "additional concerns."

In the meantime, several Dryden supporters have set up a fund called the 'Bruce Montague Scrap C-68 Fund' to help the family with legal expenses.


back to top | search | home | site map
DISCLAIMER: is maintained by friends and supporters of Bruce Montague.
It is NOT an official mouth-piece for Bruce Montague's legal defense.